KUNG FU CHIVALRY
(A Shaw Brothers Retrospective)



Spoilt for choice at this year's Telecom New Zealand International Film Festival, CALEB STARRENBURG and AARON YAP revisited three classic Shaw Bros. films, due to screen for the first time locally in their original, big screen format.


The 36th Chamber of Shaolin (1978)
Liu Chia-liang | Hong Kong | 115 min | Featuring: Gordon Liu Chia Hui, Lo Lieh, Liu Chia Yung, Sui Tien Yuen.

The 36th Chamber of Shaolin is arguably the greatest offering of The Shaw Brothers Studios' prolific production career – over 900 pictures – and a landmark kung fu film.

Also known as Master Killer and Shaolin Master Killer, The 36th Chamber of Shaolin has obtained iconic status in popular culture – parodied many times, in Hong Kong and abroad.1

Directed by Liu Chia-liang2 and starring Gordon Liu (whose recent appearance in Kill Bill Vol. 2 was the film's only saving grace) The 36th Chamber of Shaolin is broken into three distinct chapters.

In the film's first chapter Liu Yu Te (Gordon Liu) – an anti Manchu government rebel – is attacked by the 'evil' General Tien Wa (Lo Lieh). Yu Te's father is killed while helping his son escape the general's soldiers. Yu Te promises to take revenge and travels to the Shaolin Temple to learn martial arts.

The second chapter focuses on Yu Te's acceptance into Shaolin and his quest to learn kung fu. To become a great martial artist, the brash San Te (Liu Yu Te's Buddhist name) must conquer all 35 Shaolin chambers – a series of mental and physical tests.

San Te excels at the 35 challenges and as a reward is promised oversight of any one of temple's chambers. However, San Te asks to establish a 36th chamber, which will teach kung fu to the people. His request is denied and he is sent from Shaolin.

In the final chapter, San Te returns to his home where he is forced to defend himself against Manchu soldiers. An enraged General Tien confronts San Te, and a final showdown ensues.

The plot of The 36th Chamber of Shaolin may sound similar to any number of Shaw Brothers titles, and essentially it is. It is the sublime directing of Liu Chia-liang which sets this film apart. Alternating between kung fu action flick and peaceful spiritual meditation, oftentimes within the same scene, Chia-liang imbues the film with a depth not normally associated with the genre.

In his hands, a simple tale of revenge becomes an exploration of alienation, rebellion, and redemption – the rebirth and refinement of the soul.

The 36th Chamber of Shaolin succeeds largely because director Liu Chia-liang meets his goal of creating 'a love story of the spirit'. Liu Yu Te's transition into San Te is a fascinating – if unsurprising – journey that serves as an almost voyeuristic look at one man's journey of self-discovery.

That the lessons learned inside the chambers of Shaolin (thankfully we are not privy to all 35 of them) will require practical application in a climactic showdown is obvious. It is the manner in which Chia-liang and Gordon Liu apply themselves to their material, which serves to carry the audience as vicarious participants.

Gordon Liu gives in The 36th Chamber of Shaolin what is often referred to as the performance of his career, demonstrating he is not only a great martial artist, but also an accomplished actor. The authenticity he applies to the role almost convinces us of the awkward morality of the films final chapter.

"Buddhism," says San Te "Tells us to confront evil". Whether this justifies leading an armed rebellion is questionable, however the film is (apparently) based on the true story of a monk who successfully commanded an uprising.

Visually, Liu's cinematography is stunning, avoiding the static nature which characterises many early kung fu films. Despite shooting entirely on the Shaw Brother's studio lot3 with a comparatively low budget, the director utilises a clever combination of shadows and lighting to create a palpable sense of energy and intrigue.

Liu's fight choreography is also notable. The director disregards the montage of quick shots, conventionally used to construct fight scenes, instead utilising a series of impressively long takes, adding a fluidity and realism to the melees.

The innovative cinematography and choreography of The 36th Chamber of Shaolin would contribute to the film's international popularity, and establish a benchmark for future kung fu titles. It would seem San Te's desire to establish a 36th chamber and bring martial arts to the people, parodies Liu Chia-liang's desire to bring kung fu to the world.

The Telecom New Zealand International Film Festival's (NZIFF) screening of The 36th Chamber of Shaolin is possibly the first time the film has been viewed legitimately in New Zealand since the late 1970s. Sir Run Run Shaw refused to transfer his studio's films to video, or even allow them to be shown at film museums.4

For decades, Shaw Brothers Studios kung fu classics have been seen – if at all – as dirty bootlegs. These were often chopped or squeezed from their wide-screen panoramas to fit a TV format, and then dubbed into an atrociously Anglicised cacophony of grunts, death cries and manic laughter.

Finally in 2000, pan-Asian company Celestial Pictures signed an $84 million deal, purchasing 760 films from the Shaw Studio's library. Celestial Pictures, owned by American William Pfeiffer, have since been working, restoring selected films from their original source material.

Now the familiar Shaw logo – the 'SB' embossed on a golden shield – is again viewable as it should be (admittedly I have never seen it this way), in ravishing colour and wide-screen ShawScope.

The NZIFF's presentation of The 36th Chamber of Shaolin is compulsory viewing, not just for kung fu enthusiasts, but also for the wider cinema community. Enter the 36th chamber.

–Caleb Starrenburg

Come Drink With Me (1966)
King Hu | Hong Kong | 91 min | Featuring: Cheng Pei Pei, Yueh Hua, Chen Hung Lieh.

Intimate Confessions of a Chinese Courtesan (1972)
Chor Yuen | Hong Kong | 90 min | Featuring: Lily Ho, Betty Pei Ti, Yueh Hua.

A HISTORICALLY and cinematically loaded film, King Hu's Come Drink With Me not only revitalized the wu xia5 genre, but in its stylish action sequences, set a precedent for generations of Hong Kong martial arts films to come. It was the first wu xia effort for its director, the acclaimed King Hu, and the first in a trilogy which culminated in what many consider his masterpiece, the epic A Touch of Zen.

Hu's influence is evident in the works of Tsui Hark (Zu: Warriors From The Magic Mountain), Ching Siu Tung (A Chinese Ghost Story) and more recently in Ang Lee's crossover martial arts hit Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon, which paid homage to Come Drink With Me right down to the casting of its star Cheng Pei Pei in the role of Jade Fox.

In Come Drink With Me, Pei Pei plays Golden Swallow, a deadly master swordswoman who's out to retrieve her brother, a government official taken hostage by a team of bandits. Led by the ruthless Jade-Face Tiger (Chen Hung Lieh), the bandits, in exchange, want one of their own released.

Disguising herself as a man (androgyny would become a staple in wu xia films), her first stop is the inn, or teahouse, a traditional Chinese meeting place which Western viewers will recognise as the equivalent of cowboy barrooms that usually become the centre of brawls and bust-ups. Challenging the bandits single-handedly – dodging darts and fending off chairs thrown at her with a single blow – this comical and suspenseful early set piece is a great showcase for Pei Pei's skills and Hu's superb action staging.

We're also introduced us to her sidekick, a slovenly beggar named Drunken Cat (Shaw regular Yueh Hua, who was reportedly inebriated throughout the shoot). He's perhaps the film's most surprising element; in an interesting twist, Drunken Cat sheds his goofy comic relief persona, and gains a more serious, textured edge as he faces an evil Abbot whom he trained with under the same master.

As with any film carrying such historical baggage, those viewing it for the first time often wonder what the fuss is all about. If you're looking for the speedier, rat-tat-tat tempos of Lau Kar Leung's or Chang Cheh's 70s martial arts films, then Come Drink With Me will surely disappoint. The action choreography is more stilted and theatrical, bearing the influence of the Japanese samurai films of the '60s.

With Hu's fondness for Beijing opera and Pei Pei's background in dance, both director and actress complement each other perfectly. Pei Pei was only 19 at the time, untrained in martial arts, and though her inexperience is occasionally concealed in the editing, Hu lets enough long shots play out to suggest Pei Pei still had her work cut out for her. Hu's camerawork is always elegant, fluid and painterly, and perhaps the key to the film's timelessness. Pei Pei locks our eyes to the screen with a feisty and beautiful performance, her youthfulness belying her character's icy capacity to dispatch opponents without flinching.

The sets, while maintaining typically colourful, high Shaw Brothers production values, do have a theatrical look that might cause a few unintentional giggles, but it's sometimes charming in its artifice: there's a scene where a character falls into the river, and the resulting splash is clearly manufactured by having buckets of water thrown off-screen from either sides of the frame.

Hu subsequently parted ways with the Shaws – his perfectionist, individualist standards didn't gel with their studio system and populist ethos. But with Come Drink With Me, he left a crucial work in the Shaw's catalogue. Seen today, even out of context, it remains a highly entertaining, tautly spun, humorous and graceful swordplay tale that feels remarkably crisp and fresh as if it were made just yesterday.

SERVING AS A blueprint for Hong Kong's notorious Cat III flicks, Intimate Confessions of a Chinese Courtesan pushes the strong female characterisations established in '60s films like Come Drink With Me into the liberally perverse '70s. Filled with lurid sexiness, it's one of the most beautiful-looking exploitation films ever made, its mix of trashy, titillating sleaze and sumptuous production design adding to a work of pure, unaffected delirium. It's also the film that provided the inspiration for Clarence Fok's 1992 Cat III gem Naked Killer.

Intimate Confessions is directed by Chor Yuen, whose style kung fu historian Linn Haynes describes as effectively combining, "the film artistry of King Hu and the action set pieces of Chang Cheh." Proving to be the most popular and interesting discovery among the current crop of Celestial releases from the Shaw's vaults, Yuen is better known for adapting the novels of popular martial arts writer Gu Long into terrifically intricate swordplay films like Killer Clans and Clans of Intrigue. Intimate Confessions lacks the absorbing twisty plotting of those films, but compensates with a bloodthirstily linear trajectory that grows wilder with each set piece.

Lily Ho stars as Ainu, an 18-year old girl who's sold to the brothel of Lady Chun (Betty Pei Ti). Chun enjoys a healthy reputation with her clients, usually wealthy old men who bid to get their lady of choice. But when Chun attempts to initiate Ainu in the ways of the business, Ainu resists and is locked up. In her cellar, she befriends a mute boy who tries to help her escape. Failing that, she is used and abused, but also grows to be popular with her clients. She also wins the confidence of Chun, much to the dismay of Chun's business partner Bao Hu, whose repeated warnings against Ainu go unnoticed. Having fallen in love with her, Chun is oblivious to Ainu's vow to kill all her abusers. As the bodies stack up, a police officer (Yueh Hua) turns up to investigate, suspecting Ainu for the deaths, but without sufficient proof to lock her up.

One of the first things you notice about Intimate Confessions is its striking cinematography. The opening scenes are completely bathed in green, and the film continues to blind us with the lavish drapery of the sets and costumes. The intense colour Yuen splashes across the screen submerges the film in a kind of dreamy Bava-esque psychedelia. Add to that some judicious use of freeze frames and slo-mo to heighten the visceral, feverish punch of the melodrama, and you have a boldly stylish film that's as provocative visually as it is sexually.

While the eroticism here – lesbian trysts, softcore sex and nudity – would have raised many an eyebrow back then, it seems a bit tame now, but the torture scenes – crotches burnt by candles, whippings, beatings – still hold the power to disturb and make us flinch. Balancing the film's exploitative elements are the feminist themes: its underlying portrayal of men as either callow, lecherous or foolish, while Ainu constantly stays one step ahead of them.

The film's first half isn't particularly crammed to the gills with action, but the final 15 minutes are a fantastic eyeful, featuring one stunningly directed mise en scene after another. Those wonderful dolly shots following Ho as she hacks and slashes her way through dozens of men display Yuen's deft craftsmanship. The action is at once raw and blunt, and elegant and lucid. Ho really shines in a stirring, soulful performance, transforming from a stubborn, naive girl to a smart, assertive, cock-teasing femme fatale by the end. There's also some choice, campy kung fu dialogue to relish: "Your yin-yang ghost hands aren't powerful enough for my spine-chilling sword."

A real blast and a half.

–Aaron Yap

Originally published in: Lumière 4, Winter 2004, ISSN 1176-4082

(1) Pioneering New York rap outfit Wu Tang Clan paid homage to the film on their debut album, Enter the Wu Tang (36 Chambers), while Wu Tang member 'Masta Killa' takes his name from the film's alternative title. Would you tell Wu Tang member Ol' Dirty Bastard aka Big Baby Jesus aka Joe Bananas aka Osirus aka Unique Ason aka Dirt McGirt (recently released from jail for a variety of offences) you didn't like this movie?
(2) The genre's greatest artisan, Lia Chia Liang, also referred to as Lau Kar-wing, was himself a student of Shaolin martial arts. The director is renowned for casting family members in his films – Lau Kar-wing (General Yin) is Chia Liang's brother, Gordon Liu (Liu Yu Te) is Lia's half brother.
(3) The Shaw Brother's 2 million square foot studio lot, built in Hong Kong in 1958, was referred to as the Hollywood of the East.
(4) Sir Run Run Shaw – still alive and apparently sprightly at 97 – refused to transfer his films to video for fear of international video piracy.
(5) Definition of wu xia: in an article I wrote last year on the Shaw Brothers, I defined wu xia as the dumbed-down-to-the-extreme-for-the-masses, technically incorrect "sword-fighting". My granduncle Chang Kuo-sin, who was a film producer in Hong Kong from 1953 to 1960, read the article, and wrote me, correcting that error. There's more to wu xia than sword-fighting, which is only a partial component of a bigger picture. It basically describes a particular martial arts genre in literature and cinema. Wu refers to military, martial arts, chivalrous combat, fighting, etc., while xia is the knight, the swordsman, the heroic figure who fought for justice. Other elements of wu xia include the ability to fly, sorcery, elaborate weaponry, etc. In film, the term is usually wu xia pian, with pian meaning film.
In the letter he also spoke of renting out his studio to Chang Cheh, and giving King Hu his major acting role in film, and later trying to persuade Hu to return to the Shaws. On the charitable Shaws: "I at times visited Run Run Shaw in his office. The last time I visited him was at the end of 1984. Then I was Head of the Communication Department of the Baptist College, and I planned to start a film production extension course in my department. I talked to him about this. The next day he called me, asking how much I would need to start the course. I said, "One million dollars". He replied immediately, "I will give you one million dollars"...He founded a Shaw Foundation in Hong Kong. I don't know how much assets the Foundation has, but annually when I was in Hong Kong, the Foundation gave annually over HK$1,000,000 to charity. No one in Hong Kong had ever given that much to charity".
A note on the Celestial DVDs: while they are one of the best things to happen to DVD in the last couple of years, they've also been plagued by some minor problems. The early batches were non-anamorphic, and some DVDs featured subtitles that would flash twice. Currently, the only way to listen to the original mono soundtracks is to buy the cheaper VCD versions (the quality is quite good but not on par with the DVDs). Otherwise you'll have to put up with the Dolby 5.1 mix with the dreaded, already-infamous chirping birds.

Print-friendly Version | © Caleb Starrenburg / Aaron Yap / Lumière 2004 | www.lumiere.net.nz



The Lumiere Reader